Key Points (TL;DR)
- Our audit uses advanced AI to analyze publicly accessible data on your ecommerce site
- Scores reflect detected signals, not a comprehensive manual audit
- A McFadyen Digital commerce specialist reviews the findings with you to validate what matters most for your business
How AI Is Used
Our ecommerce audit platform combines advanced AI and large language models with automated browser technology to navigate and analyze your website. The AI evaluates your site across six key pillars:
- AEO/GEO — Schema.org markup, FAQ structure, AI and LLM readability
- Agent Readiness —
.well-known/endpoints,llms.txt, MCP server cards, and AI bot policy - SEO — Meta tags, headers, URL structure, sitemaps, mobile-friendliness
- Content Quality — Product descriptions, calls to action, trust signals
- Performance — Core Web Vitals, load times, resource optimization
- Accessibility — WCAG 2.1 AA compliance, keyboard navigation, screen reader support
Each pillar is scored individually and combined into a weighted overall score. The AI autonomously navigates your site using a real browser, visiting key pages and evaluating each pillar against industry best practices and established standards.
What We Analyze
Our analysis is limited to publicly accessible site data. This includes:
- Static HTML — page structure, meta tags, heading hierarchy, and semantic markup
- Crawlable structured data — Schema.org markup, Open Graph tags, and other machine-readable metadata
- HTTP headers — caching directives, security headers, and server response characteristics
- Observable technical signals — page load behavior, resource sizes, render timing, and Core Web Vitals
Pages We Visit
The AI navigates to the following page types on your site (where available):
- Homepage
- Category listing page
- Product listing page
- Product detail page
- FAQ page (if present)
- About Us page
Methodology Limitations
Because our analysis relies on automated external crawling, there are inherent limitations. Our audit may not fully reflect:
- Server-rendered content — content that depends on specific server-side conditions or user context
- Authenticated states — pages or features behind login walls, such as account dashboards or checkout flows
- CDN behavior — caching layers, edge optimizations, or geographic routing not visible to external crawlers
- A/B test variations — alternate page versions served to different user segments
- Personalized content — recommendations, pricing, or messaging tailored to individual visitors
- Geo-restricted content — pages or features limited to specific regions or countries
Note: Analysis is based on a single point-in-time snapshot. Site performance and content may vary depending on traffic, time of day, and other dynamic factors.
Scoring & Recommendations
Scores and recommendations reflect detected signals, not a comprehensive manual audit. Each pillar receives a score from 0 to 100, weighted according to its relative importance (shown in the table above) to produce an overall score.
Score Labels
| Score | Label |
|---|---|
| 90 – 100 | Industry Leading |
| 80 – 89 | Strong Foundation — Optimize |
| 65 – 79 | Improvement Opportunities |
| 50 – 64 | Significant Gaps — High Priority |
| 0 – 49 | Critical Risk — Immediate Action Required |
Findings are categorized by severity (critical, high, medium, low) and include specific recommendations. These recommendations are generated by AI based on detected issues and industry best practices, and should be validated by a qualified professional before implementation.
Human Review
This audit is a starting point, not the final word. A McFadyen Digital commerce specialist reviews the findings with you to:
- Validate which findings are most relevant to your business goals
- Prioritize recommendations based on your specific context and resources
- Identify opportunities the automated analysis may have missed
- Provide strategic guidance beyond what AI can detect
Ready to discuss your results? After receiving your report, a member of our team will reach out to schedule a review of the findings.
Data Handling
- Website URL — the ecommerce site you submit for analysis
- Company name — to contextualize your report
- Email address — to deliver your audit report
- Full name — to personalize communications
Only publicly accessible pages on the submitted URL. We do not access password-protected areas, admin panels, databases, or any non-public resources. The AI navigates your site the same way any visitor or search engine crawler would.
Audit report results are stored in secure cloud storage (Cloudflare R2) and associated metadata is stored in our database (Cloudflare D1). Reports are retained to allow you continued access to your results.
We retain your data and report results indefinitely unless you request deletion. You can request deletion of all your data at any time through our self-service deletion page.
For full details on how we handle your personal information, see our Privacy Policy.
